1. Governance
September 29, 2015

“Boris Johnson’s transport legacy has well and truly come off the tracks”

By Val Shawcross

Val Shawcross AM is Labour’s London Assembly transport spokesperson.

For Londoners, forced to witness increasingly large amounts of their pay cheques frittered away on travel costs and to struggle on to the capital’s overcrowded tubes and buses, the last seven years with Boris Johnson have been anything but a smooth ride.

The mayor once boldly claimed that, “Londoners deserve honesty and openness over fare setting. My approach will ensure that fares will be lower in the long term.” These were very warm words indeed.

But those who have seen their fares rise year after year, and have witnessed little action taken to  deliver the important transport projects the capital desperately needs, will testify that’s all there is to Boris Johnson’s pledge – warm words.

Last Christmas the mayor had ample opportunity to salvage his ailing transport legacy. Had he responded to calls to utilise £98m of Transport for London (TfL) underspends to freeze fares at 2014 levels, Boris Johnson could have saved the average commuter, travelling on a zone 1-6 Annual Travelcard, as much as £56 a year.

It was a solid proposal. With TfL consistently overestimating its operating costs and underestimating income from fares, the mayor had the capacity to provide Londoners with some much needed respite from spiralling travel costs, without impinging on TfL’s capital expenditure or reserves. 

Instead Boris Johnson bumped up fares by another 2.5 per cent taking the not-so-grand total of fare hikes across his mayoralty to a staggering 40 per cent.

Content from our partners
The key role of heat network integration in creating one of London’s most sustainable buildings
The role of green bonds in financing the urban energy transition
The need to grow London's EV infrastructure at speed and scale

For many Londoners, already struggling to cope with the capital’s high cost of living, the cumulative impact of Boris’ annual increases has simply  become too much to bear. A woman in Barnet recently told me that rising transport costs had meant that living and working in the  capital was “nearly impossible”. Sadly, she’s not alone. 76 per cent of Londoners now say that their fares are too high, with less than 1 per cent stating that they are too low.

The salt in the wounds for those unable to avoid the mayor’s perennial fare hikes is the fact that very little has been done to deliver the vital projects needed to ensure London’s transport infrastructure meets the needs of its burgeoning population and global city status.
As part of his Vision 2020, the mayor vowed that he would deliver essential upgrades to the Circle, District, Hammersmith and City, and Metropolitan Lines by 2018. But in August, with just months of Boris Johnson’s mayoral term remaining, TfL announced that this work will be delayed by five years, after a failed contract for the work cost the taxpayer over £80m.

With rush hour tubes operating at full capacity, and those on the daily commute forced to endure uncomfortably overcrowded services, upgrading the tube is, without doubt, the single most important transport project in London aside from Crossrail. The mayor’s botched attempt at delivering this project is amongst his most significant failures.

On the buses

For bus passengers, it’s not much better. Boris Johnson’s failure to address bus overcrowding is nothing new. The previous mayor boosted capacity on the network by 34 per cent – resulting in reduced overcrowding, shorter waiting times and more routes to serve a growing populous. But the predicted increase under Boris Johnson stands at a measly 4.39 per cent: bus capacity is being outstripped by population growth.

When you compare Boris’ abysmal record with his decision to send bus fares soaring by 47 per cent since 2008, it is not an exaggeration to say that London bus users are being well and truly ripped off.

Indeed there’s a real injustice beneath Boris’ blunder-ridden handling of his transport responsibilities. Consider, for example, that whilst passengers have been grappling with increasingly unaffordable transport costs, the mayor has simultaneously whittled away vast sums by cancelling some projects such as the Thames Gateway Bridge, only to reintroduce them at a later date.

Whilst the mayor’s record of delaying, cancelling or simply   neglecting vital transport projects has served Londoners so poorly, it has allowed him to allocate greater priority to other projects, however ill-judged they may be.

The much lauded Thames Cable Car project in East London, meant to cost the taxpayer no money, has actually cost £46m thus far, returning disappointing passenger numbers in the process. The new Routemaster buses have been widely criticised as “Roastmasters” after soaring temperatures left passengers sweltering. All of these pursued whilst Londoners have been forced to shell out ever greater amounts in fares.

For the many disappointed Londoners there is perhaps one saving grace to be found amongst the debris of Boris’ transport legacy – the Cycle Superhighway. But this project, intended to make our capital safer for its growing number of cyclists, took too long to conjure up. London’s cyclists were left to wait seven years before the mayor displayed any real commitment to delivering the type of cycle infrastructure that befits a capital city. Even on the promise to improve the most dangerous junctions for cyclists, by the time he leaves City Hall only 9 of the 33 will be completed.

Boris Johnson took up the mayoralty amongst great fanfare – but his transport legacy very quickly slipped off the rails, leaving already hard pressed Londoners to pay the price.


This article is from the CityMetric archive: some formatting and images may not be present.
Websites in our network